← All experiments

Experiment

Brown it, don't burn it

Golden toast isn't a little bit burnt: it's a different chemical reaction. Build it wrong first: heat bread in steam, and watch it stay pale.

From the Short "Brown Toast Isn't a Little Bit Burnt". Coming soon on YouTube

A slice of bread, cut open to show its dry surface and moist middle, either on a rack over a pan of boiling water or inside a toaster between two glowing wires, with thermometers for its surface and its middle. surface middle 20 °C surface 20 °C middle 0:00 sped up

Heat it in steam

Bread is mostly starch and water, plus a little protein and sugar. Let's just heat it: on a rack over boiling water, next to a steamed bun.

Get the bread's surface hotter than 100 °C. Try every flame, and give it time.

Flame

Surface20 °C
Middle20 °C
Water in the surface100%
ColourPale

What's going on

Bread is mostly starch and water: white bread is roughly 35 to 40 per cent water, about half carbohydrate (mostly starch), about 8 to 10 per cent protein and a few per cent sugars.

At normal air pressure water boils at 100 °C, so a wet surface is held at or below about 100 °C: extra heat goes into turning water to vapour. Steaming cooks at about 100 °C, which is why steamed breads and buns stay pale. The browning reaction does run slowly at lower temperatures, over hours in some long-cooked foods, but not in normal cooking times.

A toaster's wires glow red-hot and heat the bread mostly by radiation. The surface dries first, and only then can it climb past 100 °C. Browning becomes noticeable from roughly 120 °C and is fast at about 140 to 165 °C, depending on the food. The inside stays moist and at or below about 100 °C, which is why toast is crisp outside and soft inside.

The browning is mainly the Maillard reaction, named after the French chemist Louis-Camille Maillard, who described it in 1912. Sugars react with amino acids, the building blocks of protein, making brown molecules and hundreds of others that give the flavour and smell. Sugar breaking down on its own (caramelisation) and browning starch add some colour too, but in toast the Maillard reaction is usually credited with most of it. The same reaction plays a big part in browning seared steak, roasted coffee and the crust of a loaf.

Keep heating and the molecules break apart into a black, carbon-rich char, with bitter, acrid compounds and smoke. That's burnt toast: a different chemical reaction from browning. Left too long, toast passes from one into the other, but golden toast isn't a little bit burnt.

Simplified: the slice is worked out as thin layers through half its thickness, heated by a toaster whose wires warm up in about 15 seconds; a layer loses water only once it reaches 100 °C, and the vapour leaves at once. Browning and charring use a rough rule in which each gets many times faster as it gets hotter, tuned so a slice goes golden in about two and a half minutes. Browning is counted only once the surface layer is dry. All the times and temperatures are a rough guide. The steaming and toasting are sped up, the slice is drawn cut open as in the Short, and the molecules are simple shapes.