← All experiments

Experiment

Make a volcano fizz

A volcano is a shaken fizzy drink, with rock inside. Build it wrong first: a thin crust floating on a sea of molten rock.

From the Short "A Volcano Is a Shaken Fizzy Drink". ▶ Watch the Short

A cut-away of the ground under a plain volcano: a thin grey crust, the rock below it, a magma chamber and a pipe up to the crater, drawn as a simple diagram. seismometer Real earthquakes: shear waves cross the whole mantle thin crust a sea of molten rock? the usual picture

The usual picture

A thin crust floating on a sea of molten rock. Crack it, and up it squirts. But is that what's under our feet? Earthquakes can tell us.

Crack the crust. Then send a shear wave through each picture: which one matches what real earthquakes show?

Picture

Shear waves are the earthquake waves that liquid stops.

PictureMolten sea
Shear wave got acrossNot tried
Liquid core startsAbout 2,900 km down

What's going on

The usual picture, a thin crust floating on a sea of molten rock, is wrong. The evidence is earthquake waves. Shear waves can't travel through liquid, yet they cross the whole mantle, the layer under the crust. They don't cross the outer core. So the mantle is almost all solid rock: hot, but solid. It does flow, very slowly, centimetres a year, and parts of the upper mantle hold a small fraction of melt between the grains. The core's liquid metal starts nearly three thousand kilometres down, and magma doesn't come from there.

Magma is molten rock underground; once it reaches the surface it's called lava. Most of it forms in the upper mantle, from tens of kilometres to a little over a hundred kilometres down, or in the crust, and only part of the rock melts, commonly a few percent to about twenty percent. Where hot mantle rock rises, the pressure on it falls, which lowers its melting point: this makes the most magma on Earth. Where one plate sinks under another, water from the sinking plate lowers the melting point of the rock above. Melt from the mantle is roughly 2.7 to 2.8 grams per cubic centimetre, against about 3.3 for the rock around it, so it rises and collects, often a few kilometres to about 10 km below a volcano.

Volcanic gas is mostly water vapour, then carbon dioxide, dissolved in the magma at a few percent of its weight. How much can stay dissolved rises with pressure. As magma rises and the pressure falls, the gas comes out as bubbles, like a fizzy drink when the cap comes off, and the bubbles swell as the pressure keeps falling. A rough sum: magma holding 4% water, at the surface and about 1,000 °C, would make steam taking up several hundred times its own volume. Swelling bubbles make the magma lighter and speed its rise, which drops the pressure faster still.

The real trick is stickiness, set mainly by silica (the main ingredient of glass and quartz sand) and by temperature. Basalt, about half silica at around 1,100 to 1,200 °C, is runny. Rhyolite, about 70% silica or more at around 700 to 850 °C, can be a million or more times stickier. Runny magma lets bubbles rise through it and escape, so its eruptions are mostly lava flows and lava fountains. Sticky magma holds them. When bubbles fill roughly 70 to 80% of it, the froth breaks apart into ash, tiny shards of rock and volcanic glass, and gas, which blast out. Heat keeps the rock molten and the gas hot, but the push comes from the gas, escaping all at once. That's the shaken fizzy drink: shaking a bottle makes its gas come out all at once, which is what sticky magma does when it finally lets go. Nothing really shakes the magma.

Simplified: the layers aren't to scale and the crust is drawn thicker; the cone is a plain shape, not a real volcano. Melt is drawn rising as blobs, where really it seeps up between the grains and gathers into channels and cracks, and the chamber is drawn as an open pool, where real ones are usually a mush of crystals and melt. Bubbles are drawn far larger than real. The two ways of melting are drawn under one volcano; really they happen in different places. The gas is water only, 4% of the magma's weight, with a common rough rule for how much water sticky magma can hold (0.4 × the square root of the pressure in megapascals, as % of weight), used here for runny magma too; the pressure is the weight of rock above; the bubbles are at 1,000 °C. In step 3 no gas escapes. In step 4 the share of gas that escapes on the way up is a toy rule that falls with stickiness, and the froth bursts when bubbles fill 75% of it, near the top. Time is sped up.